Herbert v. McDonald

In 2000, Herbert, a Navy veteran, sought disability benefits for PTSD, which he alleged was connected to a typhoon that his ship encountered travelling to Japan in 1956. Ship logs and letters confirm that the USS Mount McKinley weathered a bad storm around that time. A 2002 VA medical examination revealed no PTSD; the Regional Office denied the claim. Herbert filed notice of disagreement, but his hearing did not occur until 2008. Herbert underwent a 2004 examination at the VA’s Veterans Center and a 2006 examination by a private psychologist that both produced diagnoses of PTSD. A 2006 VA examination and a 2007 examination conducted at the VA’s behest did not. The Board of Appeal denied service connection finding Herbert not credible in testifying to witnessing others go overboard. The Veterans Court remanded. A VA examiner concluded that experiencing the typhoon itself was an adequate stressor to support a PTSD diagnosis, but that Herbert’s symptoms did not meet diagnostic criteria for PTSD” In 2011, Herbert had another private medical examination, which diagnosed PTSD based on the storm alone. In 2012, the Board rejected Herbert’s claim, finding him “not credible in reporting his psychiatric symptoms or the stressors.” The Veterans Court and Federal Circuit affirmed. View "Herbert v. McDonald" on Justia Law